At first glance, this may look like a photo of some women waiting to take their clothing for a bus ride. In actual fact, it’s a sort of informal market.
It’s about 9.45 am on a September morning and I’m outside one of Moscow’s main train stations, on my way to meet some people and go for an excursion. I’m early (for once), so I’m wandering around, keeping on the move so I don’t attract hopeful taxi drivers. I notice two or three women standing in the street holding up jumpers. This seems odd, so I keep my eye on them. Before long, there’s a line of women holding up clothing, looking stoic and expressionless as only Russians truly can. Eventually one or two customers start to drift over, and I see one of the women make her first sale of the day before I have to go and catch the train.
It stuck in my mind, partly because of the questions that occurred to me – where do they get what they’re selling? How tired do their arms get? Are there unwritten rules about how long they can be there, and is that why they all turn up at about the same time? How much money do they make in a morning? – and partly because of the contrast. The building behind them in the photo is the European Shopping Mall, a big glitzy consumer palace of a place teeming with Western brands, from Italian designers to Marks & Sparks and Top Shop. Other attractions include cafes, restaurants, nail bars, a cinema and an ice rink. It gets predictably busy in the evenings and weekends. There are increasing numbers of these malls in Moscow (i.e. it’s no different from the rest of the world in that respect). So there are those who can shop in the malls, and those who shop at the markets, formal and informal. There are probably those who do both.
It strikes me that it’s a very Russian approach to buying and selling. I talked before about all the strange things you can buy in various places, but it took me a while to stop thinking about the weirdness of what people were selling and start thinking about why they were selling them. Perekhod kiosks and market stalls are one thing, but presumably these are hard to come by (knowing Russia, you probably have to fill in sixteen forms over a period of three years and give ‘presents’ to four different local officials). And that assumes you can afford the lease in the first place. But it looks like the authorities mostly turn a blind eye if someone gets on a train with a bunch of gadgets they’ve picked up cheap somewhere, or sits on a plastic stool outside the metro selling redcurrants from their garden, or stands outside a shopping mall with an armful of blouses. It seems very Russian to me because it’s pragmatic: no-one expects the official system to be the only way of doing things. You find ways round it and do whatever you can.






